Free registration is required to access these resources. Login or Register.

Premium compliance products are also available in the insideARM Store

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) has been collecting consumer complaints on credit card companies since December 2011. While most of the complaints deal with billing and account matters, about 1,600 specifically site debt collection issues. The sample provides a bit of insight into what the ARM industry will be dealing with once the Bureau begins accepting third party debt collection complaints.

In late March, the CFPB released to the public all of the complaint data it has collected so far through its Consumer Response complaint system. Going forward, the data will be updated in near-real time, providing an open environment for oversight of its complaint process. The agency encouraged the public to pore through the more than 94,000 records to find trends in complaints about financial products.

The CFPB’s complaint data is meticulously cleaned and standardized. As a media outlet that has evaluated complaints from other federal agencies, we here at insideARM.com greatly appreciate that.

A little more than a third of the total complaints contained the word “collection” in the Issue field, the label that reveals what specific action the consumer is complaining about. The Issue field in Consumer Response is comprised of pre-selected issues the consumer can choose.

The vast majority of records with “collection” in the Issue field were related to mortgages. In fact, the pre-selected language for that particular label is “Loan modification, collection, foreclosure.” Within the context of those complaints, we felt it was safe to discard them as debt collection complaints as most clearly were dealing with loan modification issues and foreclosure attempts.

So that left 1,629 complaint records with the Issue field selection of either “Collection Debt Dispute” or “Collection Practices.” All of the complaints were related to credit card products. The collection complaints are fairly evenly split between Collection Debt Dispute and Collection Practices.

The major change the CFPB is bringing to financial product complaints is the three way communication protocol facilitated by the agency. When a complaint comes in against a company, it is almost immediately forwarded to the firm for a response. Once the company responds, the CFPB checks with the consumer to make sure the response is satisfactory. Each step is recorded and available in the complaint data.

timely-response-CFPBWhen the model was introduced, many in the ARM industry feared that it would lead to increased compliance costs. The CFPB requires a company to respond in a timely manner to a complaint, so inaction is not an option. This means that staff must be dedicated to the process of responding. And, indeed, the companies that have debt collection complaints so far have responded.

Nearly 98 percent of these complaints have been met with a timely response from the target company.

Like most other fields available in the Consumer Response system, a company’s response falls under a pre-set list of selections. There was another fear that many of the complaints would require some type of relief, either monetary or non-monetary. So far, however, the vast majority (71 percent) of company responses have not involved any relief at all, and even fewer have involved monetary relief (10 percent).

Company response % of complaints
Closed with explanation 42.9%
Closed without relief 28.3%
Closed with monetary relief 10.6%
Closed with non-monetary relief 9.5%
Closed with relief 7.7%
Closed 1.1%

 

After a company responds, the consumer has an opportunity to dispute or accept the response. Of the 1,600+ debt collection complaints in Consumer Response, about 68 percent have seen company responses go undisputed. Another 10.7 percent are too recent to have gone through the process and thus have no consumer dispute record. The remaining 21 percent have seen the consumer dispute the company response.

consumer-dispute-CFPBWhen a consumer disputes a company’s response, the process becomes a bit murky. There is no data after that step in the process, but the CFPB said that it seeks in to bring a satisfactory resolution for both the company and consumer.

Based on the credit card debt collection complaints the CFPB has received so far, the ARM industry does have work ahead of it in simply responding to and closing out complaints. But the process seems to be transparent and straightforward, at least judging by the data. We’ll see what happens when the complaints start rolling in.

 


Related Products

Telephone Communication Compliance: The CFPB's Consent Orders Thumbnail

Telephone Communication Compliance: The CFPB's Consent Orders

Our Telephone Communication Compliance: The CFPB’s Consent Orders guide is designed to help debt collectors comply with consent orders that hint at telephone communication violations. The report includes easy-to-understand explanations of each consent order and a comprehensive chart of all relevant consent orders, keeping the information you need right at your fingertips! This paper has been excerpted from insideARM's larger "The CFPB's Consent Orders Regulating the ARM Industry" report, available for sale now.

Staying Compliant – and Out of Court – with the TCPA Thumbnail

Staying Compliant – and Out of Court – with the TCPA

This reference guide distills the information presented in our webinar. It comes complete with a link to the full recording of the webinar – great for use for all-staff trainings and quarterly in-services -- as well as the slide deck and full transcript of the webinar. This guide doesn’t just walk through what agencies should and should not be doing, going forward -- it contains the full Q&A from the webinar, too. (This product is approved for DBA International Certification Credit.)

The CFPB's Consent Orders Regulating the ARM Industry Thumbnail

The CFPB's Consent Orders Regulating the ARM Industry

Our guide on The CFPB’s Consent Orders Regulating the ARM Industry is the first report of its kind designed to help debt collectors comply with consent orders. The report includes easy-to-understand explanations of each consent order and a comprehensive chart of all relevant consent orders, keeping the information you need right at your fingertips! This report will be updated quarterly.

UPDATED! CFPB’s Advice to the Consumer (through March 2016) Thumbnail

UPDATED! CFPB’s Advice to the Consumer (through March 2016)

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau hosts more than 80 of the most common consumer questions about debt collection on its Ask CFPB website. And since the Bureau was created for the sole purpose of representing and protecting consumers, debt collectors need to know how the CFPB communicates with them. That’s why insideARM compiled the answers to all 88 questions in one user-friendly report. Using the CFPB’s guidance as a model for your own compliance priorities, policies and procedures means your company will be able to keep up with the Bureau before it feels the need to examine your agency. ALL ANSWERS UPDATED THROUGH MARCH 2016.

Advertisement